Astronomical School’s Report, 2017, Volume 13, Issue 2, Pages 64–67

https://doi.org/10.18372/2411-6602.13.10
Download PDF
UDC 523.4

Super-Earth at a distance of less than 1,000 AU in Solar system is absent

Vidmachenko A.P.

Main astronomical observatory of NASU, Akademika Zabolotnoho St. 27, 03143 Kyiv, Ukraine

Abstract

Numerous observations have shown that the Kuiper belt is a dynamically stable system. The source of cometary nuclei can be a scattered disk. It is an area created by outward-directed gravitational perturbations of the outer giant planets more than 4 billion years ago. The objects of the scattered disk are similar to the bodies of the Kuiper belt. But they go in their orbits for distances up to several hundred astronomical units (AU). In 2016 Brown and Batygin reported about indirect evidence of the existence of so far unknown ninth planet in the Solar system. They suggested, that orbits of 6 known trans-Neptunian objects of scattered disk are oriented so, that they can be influenced by a large, yet unknown body. We draw attention to the fact, that these 6 objects in close to their discovering moments were located at perihelion. We assume that for many orders of magnitude a larger number of the same trans-Neptunian objects should be located at a greater distance from the perihelion. Therefore, a possible number of the same trans-Neptunian objects should be counted in many thousands. We used the observation data obtained by Space Telescope “WISE” (Wide-Field Infrared Survey Explorer). It was established that there is no analogue of the giant planet Saturn at distances up to 30 000 AU. This circumstance allowed us to calculate that at distances up to 1000 AU it would be clearly visible planetary body with a radius of more than 11 000 km. That is, a planet with a possible mass of about 10 Earth masses and an “earth” density (5.52 t/m3). If we take into account that the density of the “average” trans-Neptunian object differs little from 2 t/m3, the radius of such a body will increase to 19 200 km. And then the limit of detection of the body will increase by almost 4 times: up to 4000 AU. (!) Thus, either unknown 9th planet is now even further, or our results cannot be directly scaled for the planet “Super-Earth”, which at such large distance can have a disproportionately low source of internal heat.

Keywords: transnepton objects; Super-Earth; Kuiper belt; ninth planet

References

  1. Batygin K., Brown M. (2016). Evidence for a Distant Giant Planet in the Solar System. Astronomical Journal. https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-6256/151/2/22
  2. Churyumov K.I., Vidmachenko A.P., Steklov A.F., Steklov E.A. (2013). Three bright bolides in Kiev sky on 29 March 2013. 8th Conference “Meteoroids 2013”. 26–30 August 2013. Poznan, Poland. Program and abstracts. – IAU C22, Session P12 Fireballs. Contribution No. 077. .
  3. Churyumov K.I., Steklov A.F., Vidmachenko A.P., Dashkiev G.N. (2015). Observations of fragments of cometary nuclei in the atmosphere over Kiev in the summer of 2014. 17th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”. The program and abstracts. May 20–22, 2015. Zhytomyr, Ukraine., 84-85.
  4. Churyumov K.I., Steklov A.F., Vidmachenko A.P., Dashkiev G.N. (2015). Observations of fragment of cometary nuclei in the atmosphere over Kiev. Astronomical School's Report, 11, No. 2, 99–102. https://doi.org/10.18372/2411-6602.11.2099
  5. Churyumov K.I., Vidmachenko A.P., Steklov A.F., Steklov E.A. (2015). On possible search of cometary material on the Earth surface. Near-Earth Astronomy, 153–155.
  6. Churyumov K.I., Steklov A.F., Vidmachenko A.P., Dashkiev G.N. (2016). Several twilight bolides over Kiev in 2013–2015 – fragments of comets nuclei. International conference “Meteoroids 2016”, at the European Space Research and Technology Centre (ESTEC). Noordwijk, the Netherlands. 6–10 June 2016. Poster No. 63. .
  7. Vidmachenko A.P. (2005). Sedna: the history of the discovery and its features. Astronomical almanac, 52, 201–212.
  8. Vidmachenko A.P. (2015). Dwarf planets (to the 10th anniversary of the introduction of the new class of planets). Astronomical almanac, 62, 228–249.
  9. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Activity of processes on the visible surfaces of Solar System bodies. Astronomical School's Report, 12, No. 2, 14–26. https://doi.org/10.18372/2411-6602.12.1014
  10. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Former 9th and possible future 9th planet in the Solar system. Astronomical School's Report, 12, No. 2, 86–95. https://doi.org/10.18372/2411-6602.12.2086
  11. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). The floating ices on the surface of Pluto. 18th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”. The program and abstracts. May 26–27, 2016. National Aviation University, Kyiv, Ukraine., 10–12.
  12. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Features of surface topography and the geological activity of Pluto. 118th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”. The program and abstracts. May 26–27, 2016. National Aviation University, Kyiv, Ukraine., 12–14.
  13. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Activity of processes on the visible surface of planets of Solar system. 18th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”. The program and abstracts. May 26–27, 2016. National Aviation University, Kyiv, Ukraine., 23–27.
  14. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Impact craters at falling of large asteroids in Ukraine. 18th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”. The program and abstracts. May 26–27, 2016. National Aviation University, Kyiv, Ukraine., 27–30.
  15. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Is there 9th planet in our solar system? Gamow International Conference. 14–20 August, 2016, Odessa, Ukraine., 46.
  16. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Could it be the ninth planet in the Solar system? International Conference “Astronomy and Space Physics in Kyiv University”. May 24–27, 2016. Book of abstracts. Kyiv, Ukraine., 67–68.
  17. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). So is there any 9-th planet in the Solar system? 18th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”. The program and abstracts. May 26–27, 2016, National Aviation University, Kyiv, Ukraine., 108–110.
  18. Vidmachenko A.P. (2016). Is There 9th Planet in Our Solar System? Odessa Astronomical Publications, 29, 224–225. https://doi.org/10.18524/1810-4215.2016.29.85236
  19. Vidmachenko A.P. (2017). The proposed 9th planet of Solar System at a distance less than 1000AU is absent. 19th International scientific conference “Astronomical School of Young Scientists”, May 24–25, 2017, Bila Tserkva, Ukraine. The program and abstracts., 19–20.
  20. Vidmachenko A.P., Morozhenko O.V. (2012). The study of the satellites surfaces and the rings of the giant planets. Main Astronomical Observatory NAS of Ukraine Press. Kyiv, Ltd. Dia. 255 p.
  21. Vidmachenko A.P., Morozhenko O.V. (2014). The physical characteristics of surface Earth-like planets, dwarf and small (asteroids) planets, and their companions, according to distance studies. – Main Astronomical Observatory NAS of Ukraine, National University of Life and Environmental Sciences of Ukraine. Kyiv, Publishing House “Profi”. 388 p.
  22. Vidmachenko A.P., Morozhenko A.V. (2014). The study Earth-like planets using spacecraft. Astronomical School's Report, 10, No. 1, 6–19. https://doi.org/10.18372/2411-6602.10.1006
  23. Vidmachenko A.P., Vidmachenko H.A. (2007). Is it dangerous asteroids? Astronomical almanac, 53, 195–207.
  24. Vidmachenko A.P., Steklov A.F. (2013). The study of cometary material on the surface of the Earth. Astronomical School's Report, 9, No. 2, 146–148. https://doi.org/10.18372/2411-6602.09.2146

Download PDF